“Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man’s character, give him power.” Abraham Lincoln

Libelled By A Tory.

with 4 comments

The Tories moan on a lot about freedom of speech and liberty, but when it comes down to brass tacks they’ll often close down fair criticism.

So it is with the case of Johanna Kaschke, a Tory.

According to reports on the Socialist Unity blog, she is conducting a libel action against Alex Hilton, who ran Labourhome. Alex explains the case:


As you may know, I sold Labourhome in July, though I still run it and with no interference from the new owner.

However, last year, someone started a defamation action against me over a Labourhome article and the expenses are bourne by me, they were not transferred to Progressive Media, the new owner.

So far this legal case has cost me £4,022 and it is still on-going. This is my plea to Labourhome readers for contributions towards my legal costs.

I can’t tell you too much about the case because I don’t want to annoy the court. But this is what I am comfortable telling you.

1. An active Labourhome user wrote a piece about the past of a Labour member who had defected to Respect. That person has since joined the Conservative Party.
2. The Labourhome user is also being sued by this particular Tory, who is a litigant in person and has no lawyer.
3. The offended person contact me about the piece, which I immediately deleted. I offered the front and centre spot on Labourhome to the offended person for their right of reply or to write something else of their own choice. My offer was declined.
4. Because of my actions, my lawyer says I have an absolute defence under Section One of the Defamation Act. I also have other defence strategies available, one of which is the possibility that the article was not defamatory, thought this is still being explored.
5. Because the complainant is a litigant in person, this case has been more complicated than normal and I have actually received a total of four writs before it got tidied up into one action. This is partly why this defence is so expensive.
6. Despite the likelihood that I will probably win this case, I do not have a strong prospect of recouping my costs, at least in a reasonable timescale. I don’t have the five-figure sum the complainant wants as a settlement.

I would be very very grateful if readers would consider donating any sum towards my legal costs. I built Labourhome two and a half years ago as an open forum for Labour supporters because I believed it was needed. I’m in court because of the freedom of this forum and I can tell you the whole situation is pretty depressing.

Any contribution will be gratefully received. If you don’t have any money but would like to help, please email a link to this plea for help to others who might be able to help.

Thank you so much,

Alex Hilton
07985 384 859”

I don’t like it when contentious libel actions are used to attack blogs. I urge readers to support Alex Hilton and publicize this case.

(H/T: Sociality Unity)

Update 1b:
I forgot to add the Paypal button, please donate to:
Update 1c: Hmm, seems like WordPress doesn’t like the Paypal form? not sure, I am a bit dozy at the moment so it could be me, still donate via

Written by modernityblog

02/12/2008 at 15:07

Posted in Uncategorized

4 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. […] more details see my previous post, Libelled By A Tory PS: Ms. Kaschke, if you’re annoyed at my coverage of events, Sue […]

  2. […] Informationen zum Fall und weitern damit verknüpften Klagen gibt es u.a. auf Modernity Blog und auf Socialist […]

  3. […] Cherry Short Of A…. I offer no comment, but I’ve covered it before, the Indy says it all: “Kaschke, complaints and […]

  4. […] Not forgetting Libelled By A Tory. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: